File a Claim

To file a new claim or check on an existing claim, please contact your insurance company directly using the phone number displayed below. If you are having trouble reaching the company, or if there is not a phone number listed for your company, please contact us directly.

To see more information about a company, click on its name. Some of the companies we represent offer online claims service. Use the link in the Online Claims column below to go to your company’s online claims center.

Personal

Foremost Insurance 800-527-3907 www.foremost.com
Main Street America Group 877-425-2467 www.msagroup.com
Ohio Casualty 866-255-5530 www.ohiocasualty-ins.com
Progressive 800-274-4499 www.progressiveagent.com
Safeco 800-332-3226 www.safeco.com
Selective 866-455-9969 customer1.selectiveinsurance.com
The Hartford 800-243-5860 www.thehartford.com
Utica First 800-456-4556
Utica National 800-216-1420 www.uticanational.com
Westfield Insurance 866-937-2663 www.westfieldinsurance.com

Business

Liberty Mutual Small Business https://business.libertymutualgroup.com
1-844-325-2467
Mid/Large Business
1-800-362-0000
Main Street America Group 877-425-2467 www.msagroup.com
Ohio Casualty 866-255-5530 www.ohiocasualty-ins.com
Philadelphia Insurance 800-765-9749 www.phly.com
Selective 866-455-9969 https://www.selective.com/claims-center
The Hartford 800-243-5860 www.thehartford.com
Utica First 800-456-4556
Utica National 800-216-1420 www.uticanational.com
Westfield Insurance 866-937-2663 www.westfieldinsurance.com
Zurich Insurance 800-987-3373 https://webclaims.zurichna.com/#/claims
Travelers 1-800-238-6225 https://www.travelers.com/claims/report-claim
Guard 1-888-NEW-CLMS https://www.guard.com/

Life & Health

Independence Blue Cross 800-275-2583 www.ibxpress.com
Ohio National 877-446-3010 www.ohionational.com
Cincinnati Life 888-212-6970 www.cinfin.com/claims

Quick Contact

Want to find out more about your personal insurance options?

REQUEST A QUOTE NOW!

Scroll to Top
Skip to content