Make A Payment

To make a payment on your insurance policy, please send a check to your insurance company directly using the address displayed below. If there is not an address listed for your company, please contact us directly.

To see more information about a company, click on its name. Some of the companies we represent accept payments online. Use the link in the Online Payments column below to go to your company’s online payment center.

Personal

Foremost InsuranceP.O. Box 0915
Carol Stream, IL 60132-0915
800-532-4221www.foremost.com
Main Street America GroupThe Main Street America Group
P.O. Box 2004
Keene, N.H. 03431
800-611-0958payments.billmatrix.com
Ohio Casualty 

MAIN
866-223-9928


PERSONAL LINES
800-543-1953

www.ohiocasualty-ins.com
ProgressiveP.O. Box 4640
Carol Stream, IL 60197-9601
800-888-7764www.progressiveagent.com
SafecoP.O. Box 6476
Carol Stream, IL 60197-6476
800-332-3226customer.safeco.com
SelectiveSelective Insurance Company of America
Box 371468
Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7468
888-974-7400customer1.selectiveinsurance.com
The HartfordP.O. Box 2917
Hartford, CT 06192
800-624-5578service.thehartford.com
Utica First 800-456-4556www.uticafirst.com
Utica National 800-274-1914 
Westfield Insurance

REGULAR MAIL
PO Box 9001566
Louisville, KY 40290-1566


OVERNIGHT MAIL
1 Park Circle
Westfield Center, OH 44251

800-766-9133www.westfieldinsurance.com

Business

Liberty MutualLiberty Mutual Insurance
PO Box 2051
Keene, NH 03431-7051
 https://business.libertymutualgroup.com/business-insurance
Main Street America GroupThe Main Street America Group
P.O. Box 2004
Keene, N.H. 03431
800-611-0958payments.billmatrix.com
Ohio Casualty 

MAIN
866-223-9928


PERSONAL LINES
800-543-1953

www.ohiocasualty-ins.com
Philadelphia InsurancePhiladelphia Insurance Companies
P.O. Box 70251
Philadelphia, PA 19176-0251
 www.phly.com
SelectiveSelective Insurance Company of America
Box 371468
Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7468
888-974-7400customer1.selectiveinsurance.com
The HartfordP.O. Box 2917
Hartford, CT 06192
800-624-5578service.thehartford.com
Utica First 800-456-4556www.uticafirst.com
Utica National 800-274-1914https://www.uticanational.com/make-a-payment/
Westfield Insurance

REGULAR MAIL
PO Box 9001566
Louisville, KY 40290-1566


OVERNIGHT MAIL
1 Park Circle
Westfield Center, OH 44251

800-766-9133www.westfieldinsurance.com
Zurich Insurance8712 Innovation Way
Chicago, IL 60682-0087
800-332-6641secure4.billerweb.com

Life & Health

Independence Blue Cross 800-854-5258  800-854-5258  www.ibxpress.com
Ohio National   www.ohionational.com

Quick Contact

Want to find out more about your personal insurance options?

REQUEST A QUOTE NOW!