Make A Payment
To make a payment on your insurance policy, please send a check to your insurance company directly using the address displayed below. If there is not an address listed for your company, please contact us directly.
To see more information about a company, click on its name. Some of the companies we represent accept payments online. Use the link in the Online Payments column below to go to your company’s online payment center.
Personal
| Foremost Insurance | P.O. Box 0915 Carol Stream, IL 60132-0915 | 800-532-4221 | www.foremost.com |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main Street America Group | The Main Street America Group P.O. Box 2004 Keene, N.H. 03431 | 800-611-0958 | payments.billmatrix.com |
| Ohio Casualty | MAIN PERSONAL LINES | www.ohiocasualty-ins.com | |
| Progressive | P.O. Box 4640 Carol Stream, IL 60197-9601 | 800-888-7764 | www.progressiveagent.com |
| Safeco | P.O. Box 6476 Carol Stream, IL 60197-6476 | 800-332-3226 | customer.safeco.com |
| Selective | Selective Insurance Company of America Box 371468 Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7468 | 888-974-7400 | customer1.selectiveinsurance.com |
| The Hartford | P.O. Box 2917 Hartford, CT 06192 | 800-624-5578 | service.thehartford.com |
| Utica First | 800-456-4556 | www.uticafirst.com | |
| Utica National | 800-274-1914 | ||
| Westfield Insurance | REGULAR MAIL OVERNIGHT MAIL | 800-766-9133 | www.westfieldinsurance.com |
Business
| Liberty Mutual | Liberty Mutual Insurance PO Box 2051 Keene, NH 03431-7051 | https://business.libertymutualgroup.com/business-insurance | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main Street America Group | The Main Street America Group P.O. Box 2004 Keene, N.H. 03431 | 800-611-0958 | payments.billmatrix.com |
| Ohio Casualty | MAIN PERSONAL LINES | www.ohiocasualty-ins.com | |
| Philadelphia Insurance | Philadelphia Insurance Companies P.O. Box 70251 Philadelphia, PA 19176-0251 | www.phly.com | |
| Selective | Selective Insurance Company of America Box 371468 Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7468 | 888-974-7400 | customer1.selectiveinsurance.com |
| The Hartford | P.O. Box 2917 Hartford, CT 06192 | 800-624-5578 | service.thehartford.com |
| Utica First | 800-456-4556 | www.uticafirst.com | |
| Utica National | 800-274-1914 | https://www.uticanational.com/make-a-payment/ | |
| Westfield Insurance | REGULAR MAIL OVERNIGHT MAIL | 800-766-9133 | www.westfieldinsurance.com |
| Zurich Insurance | 8712 Innovation Way Chicago, IL 60682-0087 | 800-332-6641 | secure4.billerweb.com |
Life & Health
Independence Blue Cross 800-854-5258 800-854-5258 www.ibxpress.com
Ohio National www.ohionational.com